Half the Country Thinks Sarah Jessica Parker, Beyonce and Blake Lively’s Names Should Be Illegal

I recently succumbed to a headline I couldn’t ignore. I clicked through to find this article. You can read the underlying study here or I’ll sum it up for you: 70% of Americans think married women should change their name. And 50% think it should be the law.

The most common reasons cited that a women should take her husband’s name were that women should prioritize marriage and family ahead of one’s self and that it indicates she is more committed to the marriage.

No one’s going to argue that SJP, married to Matthew Broderick for 20+ years, is less committed to her marriage than Sarah Jessica Broderick. Or that Beyonce isn’t prioritizing her Carter family over herself after Lemonade. Or that Blake Lively’s marriage to Ryan Reynolds isn’t real (it’s been almost 5 years and two kids, ladies. This isn’t Gossip Girl. It’s real life.)

Names are deeply personal. It becomes the descriptor, the embodiment, of who we are. It takes every word and every action of our being and represents it.

Say Tom Brady. Did you just picture him hoisting the Super Bowl MVP trophy? Or celebrating the victory with his beautiful wife? Or did you remember that he played at Michigan or the ordeal between he and Gooddell? They’re all true. Now say: Tom Hanks. Did you think of Forest Gump, Big or Rita Wilson? Now say: Tom Smith – who’s that?

All the same first names. All the last names have the same number of letters: 5. But vastly different responses.

Our name is like the hashtag of our life.

I have two names. The first has been always been mine. It’s the only one I use at work. It’s how I answer my phone and it’s how I still introduce myself (most of the time).

The second is my husband’s name which means it’s also my children’s. I legally took that on after we had our first child. Primarily because not having the same last name as my children and husband is PIA inconvenient.

That new and additional last name is just on paper. In my head my name is, always has been and always will be: Libby Vish.

And then one day, on paper, the hashtag was suppose to change.

I don’t dislike my married name: Libby Carl. It’s cute, endearing and sweet. I often joke that she’s much nicer than Libby Vish. (Someone once agreed with that joke a little too eagerly!)

But it feels like this whole other person that I’m just getting to know. So I combined the names: Libby Vish Carl. I like it. It’s a good fit for me. It lets me still feel like me, while acknowledging I have this new part of my life.

What’s in a name? Everything is in my name. My highs, my lows (and there are many) and everything in between. I’m thankful we all have the ability to navigate it however works best for ourselves, our marriage and our family.

Anyone else think it was weird to one day have one name and the next day another? Or was it a no-brainer? (I know we all have our own experiences that effect our thoughts. So I like hearing opinions that are different than mine.  It adds perspective to my own view.)



If you’re new (or been hanging around), I ask for two easy things: 1) Enjoy! and 2) If you do, you can commit a Random Act of Kindness by sharing this post through the convenient little buttons below (did you see this post? Performing a daily Random Act of Kindness is the fast track to happiness!)

For more like this you can follow me on Instagram or here on (my) Rabbit Trails – just enter your email address over on the right and you’ll get posts delivered straight to your inbox. I also love comments and feedback!!

6 thoughts on “Half the Country Thinks Sarah Jessica Parker, Beyonce and Blake Lively’s Names Should Be Illegal

  1. Sara says:

    Names are so important. For 26 years I was Sara Elizabeth H. Then I got married, dropped Elizabeth, and became Sara H. M. And I felt like I lost a piece of myself. I love my middle name. Fast forward a few years, I divorced the M, and changed my name back. When I married again, I kept all my names. I’m officially Sara Elizabeth H. D. And I really like it that way. I have all my names, and I chose to add my husbands name to mine. And now I feel whole.

    Great post! xoxo


    • Libby Vish Carl says:

      This makes me want to catch up right now! The last two weeks since we moved have been crazy, but it will happen (soon). The whole may have to do with Mr. TD. At least I think that’s part of why I like where my name is these days. 🙂


  2. Liz says:

    It’s a really confusing subject for me that I find myself in the middle of as well. I recently married but my husband is from Spain, where people don’t change names. I spent my whole life dreaming of when I would grow up, get married and then take my husband’s name, and now he doesn’t really want me to. He thinks I would sound like his sister with his name. Ha! Career wise, it also makes a difference. Who’s Liz Castro?? Never heard of her! It does give me pause. Is it necessary or just what we are used to?! So for now, I’m keeping my name. Time and babies may change that. We will see!


    • Libby Vish Carl says:

      In my little closed mind, it never occurred to that other countries approach this differently. Amazing that in Juan’s world, you taking his name would make him think of his sister. Seems like this is one scenario you did not dream in Spanish on Rose.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s